Midcap Funds Offer Good Returns and Safety

Midcap Funds Offer Good Returns and Safety

Published on SmartMoney.com

By Rob Wherry

November 16, 2007

INVESTMENT GURU RON BARON has a penchant for taking things over the top. Earlier this month, Baron, who runs a family of six mutual funds, assembled 4,000 of his loyal shareholders at the Metropolitan Opera House in New York City. The guests were treated to speeches by his portfolio managers, as well as corner office luminaries Millard Drexler, the head of J. Crew, and Joe Mansueto, the founder of Morningstar. Those appearances alone would have been enough to make the event a raving success, but then Baron unveiled his surprise guests: Bette Midler, Michael Bolton and Sheryl Crow.

While Baron certainly holds some newsworthy gatherings (in past events, he’s booked Elton John and Cher), we’re focusing on him for a different reason. This week, we went searching for the industry’s best midcap stock funds. We started out with a universe of 1,287 offerings and instantly cut almost 1,100 because they charged load fees. We then narrowed that list further with our usual performance and expense criteria. In the end, we came up with a list of 16 funds, two of which boast Baron’s name.

Midcap funds — those that invest in companies that typically have a market capitalization of between $1 billion and $10 billion — have proven to be a great investment, both over the short and long term. Fueled mostly by midcap-growth stocks, these offerings have returned 6.9% year to date, the best return of any broad-focused domestic equity fund group. Over the previous five years, they’ve posted average gains of 15.9% — four percentage points ahead of S&P 500 index funds. Our finalists have turned in even better performances, returning an average 20% during that time.

The managers in this space have a wide variety of stocks to pick through. Many midcaps were once small-capitalization companies that experienced healthy growth, or large-cap firms that have fallen from grace. In general, midcaps are seen as a safe harbor for many investors. They aren’t as volatile as small caps and they offer decent growth prospects that large companies can’t. They also tend to ride out turbulent markets better than their counterparts. We feel comfortable making midcaps 15% to 20% of your domestic equity holdings. “It’s a sweet spot,” says Alan Lancz, a wealth manager in Toledo, Ohio, … .

Despite the stellar performance of these funds, you still need to keep an eye on what it is that you’re buying. For example, if you use Morningstar to screen for funds, you’ll find that many multicap funds are put into the midcap category. That means you won’t get pure midcap exposure with one of these go-anywhere offerings.

Started in 1987, Baron’s midcap-growth fund, Baron Asset (BARAX1 ), has returned an average annual 18.2% since 2002, putting it in the top 15% of its category. That stellar performance is due in part to Baron’s stock-picking strategy, which favors stocks that are expected to double in price over the next three to five years. Top holdings include Vail Resorts (MTN2 ), Charles Schwab (SCHW3 ) and Choicepoint (CPS4 ). And while almost three-quarters of this 74-stock portfolio are midcaps, investors will also find a 22% stake in large caps. That’s a tribute to Baron’s buy-andhold philosophy (the fund’s annual turnover is 22%). As his picks rise in value, they are inevitably re-branded as large caps.

The Criteria The midcap funds on our list are open to new money, require a minimum investment of under $5,000 and don’t charge a load when new investors purchase shares. The funds also had three and five-year performance track records that put them in the top 25% of their category.